Some of my colleagues have been having this same debate, and I agree with Tim Wise here. Many would rather be against than for something....and that's the problem.
Read article here:
By Tim Wise
RE: criticisms, I offer part of this"final" note i give to my classes:
I once heard say "Be against nothing...just be clear what you are for"... I think this really is a motto to live by...when we concentrate on what we are against (racism, sexism, , capitalism, fascism, homophobia, etc.), we frame the struggle in terms of negatives and sooner or later can lose the true purpose of the struggle...LIFE...
"Life is your right..so we can't give up the fight..get up stand up"...Bob Marley...
...If we frame the struggle in terms of life affirming principles - peace, justice, love, sustenance...our eyez remain on the prize...
...do you want justice or do we want to end white supremacy? how you answer that question is key to victory.
Many enslaved Africans were able to keep a spirit that their slaveholders could neither understand nor possess due to iniquity (lack of righteousness). so who really is free and who really is in bondage?
...so while I want justice for all oppressed people, my pity is saved for those that believe living a lie gets them anything. I have no worries because I know truth and righteousness bring freedom that no money or power can ever buy or demand and no shackles can ever keep in bondage.
We must fight...but fight FOR us, not AGAINST anyone or anything.